Backup carrier costs spike 187% in pre-holiday freight crunch
Get tomorrow's supply chain signal
Daily supply-chain brief. Free, unsubscribe anytime.
The signal
Shippers are facing a sharp increase in contingency carrier costs as the busy holiday season approaches. According to FreightWaves' analysis of SONAR data, the Routing Guide Premium for secondary tenders climbed to 10.69% in mid-November, up 1.87 percentage points in just one week and the highest level since September.
Simultaneously, primary tender acceptance rates fell to 88.06%, indicating that carriers are increasingly rejecting initial load offers from shippers. This dynamic creates a painful squeeze on transportation budgets at precisely the wrong time.
The article explains that backup carriers, feeling the same capacity pressure as primary carriers but lacking priority status, have little incentive to haul freight below market rates when spot market alternatives are more lucrative. This phenomenon reveals a critical planning gap: many transportation managers underestimate how volatile secondary carrier availability becomes during market disruptions, particularly around holidays when capacity tightens industry-wide.
How this affects:
Frequently Asked Questions
What This Means for Your Supply Chain
What if routing guide premiums reach 12% by December 20?
Simulate an increase in secondary carrier cost premiums from current 10.69% to 12% by December 20, affecting all contract freight tenders that miss primary carrier acceptance. Model the cumulative impact on transportation spend across a typical shipper's network assuming current tender rejection rates continue.
Run this scenarioWhat if primary tender acceptance rates drop below 86%?
Simulate tender acceptance declining from 88.06% to 86% due to accelerating holiday demand. Model the cascading effect on backup carrier deployment, premium pricing, and the percentage of loads requiring spot market alternatives.
Run this scenarioWhat if spot rates spike 15% while contract premiums remain at 10.69%?
Simulate a scenario where National Truckload Index rates jump 15% due to holiday demand surge, while routing guide premiums hold steady at 10.69%. Model whether secondary carriers would defect from contract freight to spot market loads, and the resulting shortage of available contingency capacity.
Run this scenarioRelated Articles
Holiday Trucking Rejection Rates Forecast to Hit 14% as Capacity Tightens
Nov 20, 2026
Spot Rates Surge 50% as Peak Season Arrives with Severe Capacity Crunch
Nov 17, 2026
Rejected Loads Cost Shippers 20% More: New Data Reveals
Oct 23, 2026
Get the daily supply chain briefing
Top stories, Pulse score, and disruption alerts. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
