Back to Intelligence
Risk & Disruption
High Impact

J.B. Hunt faces negligent hiring trial over fatal crash case

Share

Get tomorrow's supply chain signal

Daily supply-chain brief. Free, unsubscribe anytime.

The signal

In a mixed ruling from an Arizona federal court, J.B. Hunt's brokerage arm won dismissal of vicarious liability claims but lost its bid to dismiss a negligent hiring claim stemming from a fatal 2023 crash. The case stems from an October 2023 collision on U.S. Route 160 involving a truck driver employed by Borderlanders Inc., a carrier booked through J.B. Hunt's platform.

The crash killed two adults and seriously injured three children, leading to the lawsuit by Crystal Gee, guardian of the injured children. The court's decision hinges on whether J.B. Hunt should have reviewed Borderlanders' publicly available safety records, including FMCSA scores and accident history, before selecting the carrier. Judge Stephen McNamee ruled that sufficient evidence exists for a jury to find that J.B. Hunt knew or should have known of safety risks associated with Borderlanders.

This ruling marks a significant development in broker liability law following the Supreme Court's decision in Montgomery vs. Caribe Transport II, which narrowed brokers' previous federal defense protections. The case signals a critical shift in how freight brokers will be held accountable for carrier selection decisions. Unlike traditional vicarious liability claims, which the court dismissed, the negligent hiring claim focuses on broker due diligence practices. This distinction creates operational implications for the brokerage industry, potentially requiring enhanced carrier vetting protocols and documented safety assessments before load assignments.

Frequently Asked Questions

Get the daily supply chain briefing

Top stories, Pulse score, and disruption alerts. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.